MOST POWERFUL MacBook vs PC Laptop (RIP Windows?)
899,529
Published 2023-12-20
Or, shop the look I'm wearing:
⮕ 24 Trouser: bit.ly/3RiGnmD
⮕ The Knitted Crew: bit.ly/3GF2mzi
⮕ Cuban Collar Shirt: bit.ly/3Gzyog1
MacBooks have always been overpriced, slow, and they can't even get over 95 FPS when gaming on Counterstrike... At least, that is what's been thrown around internet forums for the better part of the last decade. With Apple's new M3 Max chips though, are those shiny MacBooks finally able to compete with Intel and Nvidia's most powerful systems?
Keyboard I use for both Mac and PC (Nuphy Air75 V2):
⮕ From Nuphy's website (use code CT10): crtd.tech/air75v2
Products featured in this video:
⮕ Lenovo Legion 9i: howl.me/clPdCx5suBy
⮕ Aluminum Laptop Stand: geni.us/mstand
⮕ Dell U2720Q 4K Monitor: geni.us/4kdisplay
⮕ Anker USB-C Hub: geni.us/ankerhub8in1
⮕ CalDigit Thunderbolt 3 Dock: geni.us/tbdock
FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS FOR THIS VIDEO:
Q: There are cheaper Windows laptops with similar performance to the Legion 9i, why didn’t you use them?
A: Sure, but I only own the Legion 9i, and didn’t want to spend thousands more on a new one lol. The 9i also has a very comparable screen to the M3 Max MacBook Pro (3.2k resolution and Mini-LED screen). Regardless, price is not what I’m comparing in this video. I’m mostly interested in raw performance (but yes, you can get a similarly powerful Windows laptop for 20-40% cheaper than the M3 Max).
Q: During the Resident Evil gaming comparison, why did you enable DLSS on the Legion laptop? Wouldn’t it be fairer to disable this because the Mac does not support it?
A: I think it's more unfair to intentionally handicap the Legion by disabling DLSS. If you're playing on an RTX GPU, you are going to enable DLSS. The Mac has no raytracing support yet on games, so this is a realistic representation of real-life differences. There is also no DLSS option for "quality" on the Windows machine either.
Q: You look like an Apple fanboy, therefore all the data in this video is inaccurate/fake/biased.
A: IDGAF, and also feel free to compare the results in this video to other publicly available data/benchmarks/results. I did this before releasing the video to cross-reference my findings. I’m confident this video paints an accurate picture of (most) differences.
Q: Why did you compare Intel 13th generation CPUs instead of the new 2024 Intel Ultra lineup?
A: Pretty simple lol - the Ultra lineup was released about 4 days before I uploaded this video. Also, the high-performance Ultra CPUs have not even been announced, let alone the laptops they will ship in.
Support the channel:
🖥️ Custom macOS wallpapers: crtd.tech/wallpapers
📷 Follow me on Instagram: www.instagram.com/createdtech
00:00 Introduction
01:02 A Few Things…
03:05 CPU Performance
04:23 Creative Workflows
05:31 LESTRANGE Clothes
06:58 Video Editing
08:13 3D Workflows
09:44 Gaming
11:55 Fan Noise and Heat
13:07 Efficiency
13:55 Performance on Battery
14:17 The Future
#m3max #intel #gaminglaptop
--
Disclaimer: Some of the above links are affiliated, and we may receive a small commission (at no cost to you) if you make a purchase. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchase
All Comments (21)
-
Someone asked me what the keyboard was at 09:20, it's the Nuphy Air75 V2 wireless mechanical keyboard. I use it to switch between both my Mac and PC, plus it's also great for gaming. You can use code CT10 for a 10% discount: crtd.tech/air75v2
-
M3 performance looks great, but in 2023 / 2024 I simply won’t buy a laptop if not even the ssd and ram are upgradeable. It’s an ethics concern at this point.
-
Macbook: "It's over Windows, I have the highground." Windows: "I can also play games though." Macbook: "F*CK!"
-
I got my Legion 9i Pro 4090 in December 2023 (Same time as this Video for $2499.00) The MacBook is still $4000.
-
M3 wins = praised M3 for winning. Windows wins = still praised M3 for catching up with Windows.
-
Price to performance is won by Apple??? Some of the posters below me seem to scoff at the idea that people are concerned about upgradability, yet ignore that you can get a 32GB dual SSD in RAID laptop with a dedicated GPU (4060) for 70% what an equivalently performing Macbook would cost. Battery life and HEAT Apple trumps in spades, but there is more to buying a laptop than that. A LOT more.
-
It is an exciting time for chips. The next couple years should release a bunch of surprises. Apple and AMD really motivated the market to innovate. As always I don't think anyone is cross shopping these laptops. Windows is best at 80-90 percent of flagship abilities for 30% the cost.
-
My recommendation is to buy both mac and PC and whichever is respecting the consumers needs is the one to stick with. I have PC for upgradeability and mac for portability. PC desktop is best for upgrade paths and macbook is nearly unbeatable for portability and great battery life.
-
Thanks a lot for doing this exact comparison. I've been waiting for this video on youtube for months. Great video :)
-
Really appreciate the effort put into making this video! Great comparison!
-
Wow, crazy high quality of comparison review. Content and visuals are top notch.
-
I upgraded from the i9 MacBook Pro to the M3 and I seriously feel like an alien made the M3, the efficiency jump is ridiculous. Not a single hitch, it feels so strange to not fight with the system at all. No lag at all or waiting for anything.
-
M3 is epic and it uses 1/3 wattage. Incredible efficiency.
-
It's efficient but the price is not as efficient as their efficiency
-
If resident Evil Village were on max settings for both windows ad MacOS that means that the PC was doing a lot more. Windows version supports hardware RT so that would make it much heavier
-
A couple months ago I was give by my employer an M1 Macbook 14 and I really enjoyed the general experience of using it, but had to switch to a windows laptop because the Mac didn't handle working with game engines very well, but this and future M-chip macbooks look like they'll be viable for game development. Now if only the EU would force apple to make macbook hardware upgradeable down the line....
-
Considering one platform can do it all (Windows) and the other platform (macOS) will require you to buy a separate machine if you want to do gaming, I think it's safe to say that many many people will choose Windows simply for the fact that they don't want/have the room for 2 systems. The GPU performance of the M3 is also not at all on the same level as Nvidia or AMD. Apple will have to up their GPU performance significantly if it wants to be able to compete in gaming. Until then, I guess we still have to buy Windows. Which is a shame really because macOS is quite nice for work tasks and the physical quality of their computers are really nice. Hopefully this M-adventure is the start of something great and Apple will continue their efforts into real gaming and not just mobile gaming..
-
Unbelievably Fantastic review there. It is now for the buyer to weigh priorities and decide. Thanks 👍
-
What about the 7i pro with the 13900hx and 4090? This can be had for $2500 currently. Thousand dollars cheaper than the 9i pro with the water cooled vram and carbon fiber lid….
-
Thank you very much for the detailed tests!!!
