Why Is It So Hard to Stop Meltdowns?

To try everything Brilliant has to offer—free—for a full 30 days, visit brilliant.org/AtomicBlender The first 200 of you will get 20% off Brilliant’s annual premium subscription!

At 16 years old, my physics teacher took us on a day trip to the Aldermaston nuclear research site. I stood on the reactor core and the thought of all that energy, just inches below, blew my mind.

As Albert Einstein said: "It's a hell of a way to boil water"

thankfully modern reactors (generation 3 and up) have passive safefy mechanisms to prevent meltdowns from happening at all. these safety mechanisms are designed on top of the laws of physics themselves, so they can't just be disabled.

Feels like we can do this 1000x safer nowdays, than in the 60-70's, when the plants that actually have meltdown was built. But for some reason we expect nuclear to be just as unsafe, it's like comparing an car from 1970 with one form the 2020s, there has been huge leaps in design and meterial science since then but apparantly not when it comes to Nuclear Plants?

decay heat after shutdown is mainly from the decay of fission fragments not from delayed fission. Not in the first 30s but after 5 minutes the decay heat is ~100x greater then delayed fission.

Commercial plants can learn a lot from US Navy ship-based reactor plants. Lots of safety built in. Very few accidents even though the fuel is HIGHLY enriched. --US Navy veteran nuclear reactor operator

Depends on the type of reactor, fuel type, coolant used,etc. Gen 1 and 2 reactors were very dangerous. The new gen 3+ are usually bullet proof. Molten salt one are excellent

Meltdown is one of those buzz words. We like to think of it as an unintentional energy surplus - Mr Burns

Quite a big omission in this presentation is that Fukushima didn’t suffer meltdowns, they suffered Melt-throughs which is different in that the cores ( which they still aren’t sure where they are) , melted through the concrete.

For me, the most mind blowing thing about this subject is the speed at which these things happen . These are not chemical reactions, these are atomic reactions that happen almost at the speed of light. Amazing. I always found it astounding how the entire pit in an abomb is consumed so quickly

It’s hard to stop a meltdown, but it’s even harder to start one

The dangerous thing with these water cooled power plants is not the nuclear material but the water that is supposed to cool it. If the circulation of water stops the temperature of the water will increase tremendously. At 700 degrees centigrade large amounts of hydrogen is created and eventually this hydrogen will explode. The result is that nuclear material is blown up in the air and spread over a large area. In Fukushima all procedures for handling the reactor worked but since the tsunami had knock out all the backup diesel generators the circulating pumps had no power and did not work. What you see on the footage from the accident is not a nuclear explosion but one that is caused by the hydrogen. Similar things happen at Chernobyl and Three Mile Island. If you have one reactor that is not cooled by water under high pressure this would not happen. That is one of the benefits with molten salt reactors.

Funny enough, the guys at Oak Ridge that worked on PWR reactors for the Navy said: 'yeah they work great. Right up to about 60mw' after that you are ****ing insane'

Dyatlov is currently watching this on the toilet.

Thanks for another video. I would add Chernobyl was dual use reactor (military/civilian) from very different time and culture... After Fukushima they made stress tests at our local reactor, it was found a few ordinary fire engines can be used as a back up for existing 2 or 3 backups.

At 11:08. That is a BIG generator engine over that guys right shoulder. It looks like an EMD 2 stroke diesel, much like what EMD used in diesel electric locomotives for a LOOOONG time. They are still very common, super reliable, and very easy to repair and get parts for. That was an excellent choice for the power unit for a standby generator. Those engines are known for dependability and ruggedness. Fun fact! Just above the red writing on the side of tge engine is a valve. There is one of every cylinder. Those are blow down valves. They go directly into the combustion chamber, and are used to vent any possible moisture or oil buildup on the top of each piston from them not having been run for periods of time. If there was water or oil on the top of the piston, at best it could hydrolock the engine, at worst, it would bend or break that cylinders connecting rod and or piston. Fun fact 2: the older Detroit Diesel engines that were also used as generators, truck engines, and various other industrial applications worked almost identically to this monster EMD engine. From the individual self contained injectors with individual fuel racks to meter the fuel amd therefore engine speed, to having to have forced induction to even run, they are the same. Locomotives generally had a superturbocharger that acted as a supercharger at idle being driven by the crankshaft via an overrunning clutch, and at higher loads and RPMs they acted as a turbocharger, being driven bu the exhaust gasses.

You'd have to ask my wife why it's impossible to stop her meltdowns. Usually I grab the kids and hide two counties over till she offers up cash or expensive electronics in exchange for our return. I'm pretty sure at least one of her therapists has attempted suicide, I blame my wife but yeah once a meltdown starts you just gotta let it burn out.

The power output of a pressurized light water reactor, the type sane countries use, is not controlled by the control rods when steady state in the power range. Yes, they will have an immediate effect on power, however the core is designed to automatically match the thermal power of the boilers without any control rod movement. RBMK cores have an active, automatic control rod system because they do the opposite, any power imbalance between the core and boilers amplifies itself causing either a shutdown or power spike if not corrected.

With the advancement of SMRs hopefully in the near future factories could be powered by those allowing for far less strain on the power grid while also allowing them to act as power stations. I’d love if Conesville got a SMR for its business park.