In Depth Q&A: Mearsheimer and Varghese disagree on US Grand Strategy, Ukraine, Russia and China.

Published 2023-11-06
PART 2. Following a lecture from Professor John Mearsheimer in Brisbane on Monday, 23 October. Professor Mearsheimer and Peter Varghese sat down for a lively question and answer session with Tom Switzer. This video is Q&A session that followed John's lecture, you can find the lecture in PART 1 here;    • Israel-Hamas, Ukraine-Russia and Chin...  

The focus of the lecture and Q&A session was on the Middle East crisis and its potential consequences for Israel, its neighbours, and U.S. foreign policy, particularly Israel's response to Hamas, which could inflame tensions across the Middle East. The event also explored the evolving dynamics between the U.S., Russia, and China, examining whether Russia could have been an ally in containing China and the consequences of the U.S.-supported campaign in Ukraine. Mearsheimer emphasises the risks of American focus shifting away from East Asia due to ongoing conflicts with Israel-Hamas, Ukraine-Russia taking all the bandwidth.

Question 1. @RealDrewPavlou Drew Pavlou tests Mearsheimer on remarks -- 'Why should we listen to you when it comes to Ukraine, when you've been wrong over and over and over again?' John sees it as an inditement and follows up with a firm recommitment to his previous comments.

Question 2. On Anthony Albanese's State visit to China. What should the appropriate trade and investment relationship be for Australia and China?

Question 3. David Stevens. Can Putin's invasion of Ukraine be seen as a litmus test for an advance by China on Taiwan? -- Strategically, when do you think China will make a move on Taiwan?

Question 4. Owen Zheng. Beijing's Belt and Road Initiative forum recently highlighted a success story -- the Indonesian high-speed rail project, Whoosh. What do you think an industrialised and modernised Indonesia means for Australia?

Question 5. As recently as 2021, it was seen that the number 1 global conflict emerging beyond our shores was the Taliban reclaiming of Afghanistan. Is it the case that we have just abandoned Afghanistan, and is that the right move?

Question 6. If you were put in the position of negotiating an exit from the Ukraine-Russia War and deescalating the Israel-Palestine conflict, how would you go about talking to the other players that are a part of getting a political solution to ending these conflicts?

Question 7. India Economic Strategy. Where do you think Australia stands in relation to India with the added complexity of current issues in Canada. Especially with how the politics in India is changing, especially in the treatment of minorities including Muslim Sikhs.

Question 8. Why do we want to be turning continually towards American leadership? Is that the best way of achieving goals toward safety of people, economic develop and harmony. At what point do we focus on agendas other than American hegemony.

Question 9. How does India start to change the balance of power?

Question 10. Is there room for expansion in AUKUS like there was with NATO in Europe, or will we see NATO come to Asia?

You can see our other video's with Professor John Mearsheimer here;

👉 Israel-Hamas, Ukraine-Russia and China: John Mearsheimer on why the US is in serious trouble!    • Israel-Hamas, Ukraine-Russia and Chin...  

👉 Can China rise peacefully? John Mearsheimer | Tom Switzer    • Can China rise peacefully? John Mears...  

👉 John Mearsheimer | The liberal international order    • John Mearsheimer | The liberal intern...  

👉 China debate: John Mearsheimer | Hugh White | Tom Switzer    • China debate: John Mearsheimer | Hugh...  

CIS promotes free choice and individual liberty and the open exchange of ideas. CIS encourages debate among leading academics, politicians, media and the public. We aim to make sure good policy ideas are heard and seriously considered so that Australia can prosper. Follow CIS on our Socials;

Twitter - twitter.com/CISOZ
Facebook - www.facebook.com/CentreIndependentStudies/
Linkedin - www.linkedin.com/company/the-centre-for-independen…
Telegram - t.me/centreforindependentstudies

📖 Read more from CIS here: www.cis.org.au/
💬 Join in the conversation in the comments.
👍 Like this video if you enjoyed it and want to see more, it really helps us out!
🔔 Subscribe to our channel and click the bell to watch our videos first:    / @cisaus  
⏲️ Missed this event live? Subscribe to CIS to be up to date with all our events:
www.cis.org.au/subscribe/
📝 Subscribe to CIS mailing list- www.cis.org.au/subscribe/
💳 Support us with a tax-deductible donation at - www.cis.org.au/support/

All Comments (21)
  • @johnm7267
    The first speaker said Australia has benefited a great deal with its relations with America. It has benefited a great deal more with its relationship with China. The host said Russia illegally invaded Ukraine the first time any country has invaded a sovereign county, since the world war. America has illegally invade 13 countries since 1949.
  • @D4NK1
    "first time we've seen an invasion of another nation state since WW2" Wow....is he for real?
  • @scottsum1319
    The most profound Mersheimer quote for me is (paraphrasing) "If Australia & the US wants to fight Russia in Ukraine, then let the Australians kids & Americans go fight the Russians in Ukraine. The war would come to an end very quickly". I hope people let that sink in when they want to promote war
  • @shouningliu00
    I’m Chinese, and I find how hard it is for the westerners to be just humble a little bit, willing to take a closer look at China and learn something little deeper.
  • @4700_Dk
    “ To be an enemy of the U.S. is dangerous, to be a friend is fatal. “ Henry Kissinger
  • @mattjoy
    It just goes to show how mature and professional John is in this video, he shows this when talking to people who are completely disconnectd with realaity.
  • "The first time a sovereign nation invades a nation-state" "Stand up for the little guy" Laughs in Korea, Guatemala, Vietnam, Cuba, Iraq, Afghanistan, Syria
  • @rhafasusanto1394
    John Mearsheimer, indeed one of the endangered species of our time as far as global issues are concerned, is incredibly brilliant
  • @paulwilliam8412
    We should always listen to folks like Mearsheimer. He's a truth teller with no agenda or paymasters
  • @jklee5419
    40:00 Questioner: why we should support the US hegmony? Mearsheimer: what you want doesn't matter. Only what the US wants matters.😂😂
  • @milosdunjic8718
    I am always amazed by the completely incorrect view that Russia’s Special Military Operation in Ukraine is the first example of breach of a sovereign country’s territorial integrity and international law in Europe since WW2 (as moderator proudly and confidently announced 😉) … actually in 1999 NATO invaded Yugoslavia … mainly from the sky, but nevertheless invaded it, breached its territorial integrity and facilitated annexation of part of its territory (Kosovo & Metohia). All without UN approval. I believe that moment opened Pandora’s Box and announced to the world that unipolar world isn’t about respect for international law but about maintaining hegemony
  • @checkmilu
    John is so clear and real. Unfortunately we have too many confusing leaders in power. it's also unfortunate to have too many uneducated and emotionally unstable like Drew Pavlov who don't understand anything of what's John has been talking about.
  • @johnchristie162
    Firstly a big thanks to CIS for arranging this talk/discussion as this opportunity seldom happens. John Mearsheimer has a gift in that his presentation is devoid of waffle. His presentations are clear and succinct unlike most geopolitical discussions so his views become much more convincing. Thanks
  • @Cj2o
    John not only mopped the floor with his counterpart, but with that ding-a-ling that asked the 1st question. Great Q&A session, CIS.
  • @user-wm1lx7eo8z
    I'm surprised that among such intelligent people John Mearsheimer happens to be the only person keeping the open mind and being focused on true facts. Everyone else seems interested in only keeping their illusions about Putin and China persistent and spreading their delusional views around.
  • @rob_one4511
    How do such ignorant and naive questions pass the vetting process. We just embarassed ourselves in front of John. Well done CIS. 😑
  • The first questioner, it looks like he had not listened to Professor because in many discussions he had explained this Ukraine situation.
  • @VichoBandido
    A client state of the US does not have full sovereignty either!
  • @Frip36
    Drew Pavlou being THAT guy who turns question into never ending harangue. Won't stop when he's asked to stop. 13:20
  • @johnbolger2625
    Mearsheimer is knowledgeable and reasonable. I find it kind of sad at a 2023 geopolitical talk of Australia and the US alliance that there’s no Q & A of the Assange issue. It’s an unprecedented move by the US to attempt to charge an Australian citizen publisher (not whistleblower) under the espionage act