Old & New Prologue Comparison

I like how the fallen hero’s are like: “Hey, we have power. Let’s create chaos.” And the ancient hero’s are like: “Hey, we have power. Let’s save the world”

Old prologue: Peace of the cookies but bad witches New Prologue: Being nice to cookies and create a world for the cookies to live in peace but many bad cookies abuse their creations

I like how one witch wants to create chaos but one just wants peace and prosperity but failed 😞

Original prologue: In the distant past, after the chaos of iron & flame subsided. New trailer: In the distant past, when the chaos of iron & flame still reigned. So, one possibility is that there are different kinds of Witches (good & evil) OR something happened to the Witches during the end of the chaos of iron & flame that turned them bad.

Simple fix: Be the Pure Vessel from Hollow Knight. Then you can't be evil

The soul jam have their own will and ideals don't they? Like Pure Vanilla's Soul jam defines truth, Hollyberry's defines passion and so on. I wonder if the original holders had different ideals assigned to them, the only thing I can grasp is how Shadow Milk's design is a jester, which contrasts to Truth, they define Foolery and Lies which is completely the opposite of Pure Vanilla's Soul Jam's ideals.

Shadow Milk Cookie - Pure Vanilla Cookie Eternal Sugar Cookie - Hollyberry Cookie Mystic Flour Cookie - Dark Cacao Cookie Burning Spice Cookie - Golden Cheese Cookie Silent Salt Cookie - White Lily Cookie

I imagine that sometimes when Pure Vanilla looks into the mirror,he can see White Lily somewhere within the reflection as just a mere shadow.He’d turn around,thinking she was back but would see nothing.I’d also imagine that White Lily since she's now Dark Enchantress,she roams within the reflection of things,but disappears the moment she’s seen,seeing as Dark Enchantress has taken her over and maybe that’s just her soul roaming around.

Witches be like: help my afternoon tea is starting a war 😭😭

I need more lore about the wizards.Imagine witches vs wizards

My theory is the witches are seperated into two camps, the first camps is the white witches wich is the good witches, in the other side there's the second camp, Black Withches wich is the bad witches and thats why there is a witches that want to make chaos upon the earthbread and the other one want to make peace and harmony upon the earthbread

The lore is so different the witches are now evil but they weren't before!? Or are they the good witches?And the most important question is will my data survive!?

My theory: Since White Lily Cookie knew cookies were meant to be eaten she became Dark Enchantress Cookie and decided to go to Beast-Yeast and then, she saw the 5 fallen heroes emprisoned. She decides to free them in order to beat the Witches and came back in Earthbread with one only goal: take the Soul Jams. In fact, the fallen heroes manipulated her just to became what they used to be. She then proceeds to take their Soul Jams and fly away. Unfortunately, the journey to Beast-Yeast took too long and the Soul Jams came back to their "owners." Now I answer some questions I might get: How does she knows The Beast-Yeast Continent? White Lily studied at Blueberry Institute and found out about the Beast-Yeast continent. Why "owners"? Since the current Owners of Soul Jams are derived from The fallen heroes' First Soul Jams. Like Pure Vanilla's Soul Jam is from Shadow Milk's Soul Jam, Hollyberry's Soul Jam is from Eternal Sugar's Soul Jam, Dark Cacao's Soul Jam is from Mystic Flour's Soul Jam, Golden Cheese's Soul Jam is from Red Spice's Soul Jam, And White Lily's Soul Jam is from Silent Salt's Soul Jam.

I like how dark enchantress cookie is the narrarator of the original prologuw

0:22 linzer cookie's necklace thingy

Old prologue : real witch voice New prologue : man voice?

What we need is some good lore about the Witches.

THEORY The original prologue is the second phase, the new trailer is the first phase. As said when chaos still reigned AND when chaos has subsided. The first witches were good, wanting to extinguish the flame and chaos into the world. So they made cookies; the first five or The Fallen. The Fallen did their hero stuff, saving worlds, building kingdoms, but one by one they became infected in a way. They became chaotic, tyrants, destroyed everything in their path. They became corrupted and destroyed everything. That’s because they were the first creations, they are bound to have imperfections and some defects. With the witches seeing what their creations have done. They locked them up, of course with leaders being locked up. There are still the people right? The other cookies or the Fallen’s followers. The corrupted things that the ancients fight in the original prologue. You can’t really lock up EVERYONE right? IK, it’s fine be a wild jump but I think the witches ate the others. HERE ME OUT: Now the witches wanted to attempt again making powerful cookies, using the soul jam of the fallen/former five. They made new, powerful cookies, the ancients. And now yada yada, building kingdoms, leading others. But as the original prologue stated, chaos emerged. Which I suspect is the remaining followers of the fallen. The ones that didn’t get eaten. Cmon knowing that your leaders dies, then replaced by new people? That’s got to make them fight the ancients right? A revenge sort of thing. Now with one of the ancients, white lily cookie. She may have become corrupted as well. Because we know she is kind, and gentle. Unlike the other ancients which have strong wills. That’s the problem, SHE IS TOO KIND AND GENTLE. She may have been convinced by the followers of the fallen. Maybe she spoke to them, talked them to stop the fighting. But instead they managed to convince her to join their side. Telling her that the first Five were imprisoned, and the others were eaten. That’s how she knew and came to conclude that cookies were made to be eaten. So she rebelled against the ancients and joined the darkness. Now note the difference of the narrators between the two videos. First was an old female, second was a male. The female narrator may be dark enchantress cookie, painting the witches in a bad light since that’s what she thinks they are. They are gods that made cookies just to be eaten, when in reality. That’s not the case, they HAD to eat them to STOP THE CHAOS. For a clean slate. There are no bad witches, only good ones. Dark Enchantress cookie only makes them look bad. Now dark enchantress cookie, believing that she is right and everybody against her is wrong. Is now on her way to free the fallen or the first five. Pure Vanilla Cookie knows this, because they USED to be classmates, USED to be so close, USED to be the bestest of friends. He knows what white lily cookie is plotting. That’s why it is shown in the new trailer that he is aboard an airship. Trying to beat white lily cookie/dark enchantress cookie to the locations of the first five. Trying to stop the first five from being freed so that the world won’t turn into chaos again. I called the first batch of cookies the: First Five or The Fallen NOTE: I KNOW my theory has a lot of holes, like what about the wizards? but I think it’s pretty plausible seeing what the game showed us lore wise so far. Remember friends, that’s just a theory. A GAME THEORY THANKS FOR READING

love how in the old one the witches are pictured as an "evil deity" while the new version picture them as the good one 💀💀

How am I so early The old one makes the witches look evil while the new one makes them look nice