This Freeway Sucks -- Let's Decommission It

171,162
0
Published 2024-05-08
The vast majority of urban freeways were built in the mid-20th century. This means that, structurally, many are reaching the end of their useful life, so state DOTs are looking at rebuilding -- or even rethinking altogether. So what should we do with our deteriorating freeways? Well, in the Twin Cities, they have ideas.

----------

CityNerd is on Nebula, the creator-owned streaming service, ad-free! Using my custom link gets you 40% off an annual subscription, and really helps the channel! go.nebula.tv/citynerd

Also STILL available: the Lifetime offer! $300 for Nebula as long as both you and Nebula exist, and a full 1/3 of the price goes directly to support this channel. go.nebula.tv/lifetime?ref=citynerd

----------

Special thanks to Segregation By Design for use of the I-94 animation. They do fantastic work at educating and raising awareness about the historic and ongoing harms caused by redlining, urban renewal, and freeway construction. Check out the site here and consider supporting their excellent work: www.segregationbydesign.com/

----------

Special thanks to Our Streets for use of assets from the Reimagining I-94 report, and all the groups who helped put on the Slow Roll event. Consider supporting the great work all these organizations do!
- Our Streets does amazing work, and they really depend on contributions (and volunteerism!) from people who care: www.ourstreetsmn.org/get-involved/donate/
- streets.mn: streets.mn/
- Bicycle Alliance of Minnesota: www.bikemn.org/
- And if you're in Minneapolis, check out Venture Bikes: venturebikesmn.com/

Also, read Luke Birtzer's excellent recap of the Slow Roll event here!
streets.mn/2024/04/22/a-city-nerd-bike-party-and-l…

----------

Patreon - a way to directly support continuing CityNerd output! Thanks to all who have signed up so far.
www.patreon.com/CityNerd

----------

Previous CityNerd Videos Referenced:
- What makes Minneapolis great:    • What the Twin Cities Do Better Than A...  

----------

Resources:
- MNDOT's Rethinking I-94 site: talk.dot.state.mn.us/rethinking-i94
- Read Our Streets' report, "Reimagining I-94": www.ourstreetsmpls.org/converting_stretch_of_i_94_…
- Star-Tribune's piece on Our Streets' I-94 effort: www.startribune.com/group-pushes-replacing-i-94-be…
- Congress For the New Urbanism's 2023 Freeways Without Futures list: www.cnu.org/highways-boulevards/freeways-without-f…
- The Malcolm Willey House: www.thewilleyhouse.com/
- Visit St. Paul's piece on Anthony Taylor and Slow Roll MSP: www.visitsaintpaul.com/blog/meet-anthony-taylor/
- NCHRP report on interchange spacing: www.cmfclearinghouse.org/studydocs/nchrp_rpt_687.p…
- President Biden's Reconnecting Communities grant announcements: www.transportation.gov/briefing-room/biden-harris-…

----------

Images
- Thanks to Our Streets and Luke Birtzer at streets.mn for use of additional photos from the Slow Roll event at Venture Bikes Midtown

----------

Instagram: @nerd4cities
BlueSky: @nerd4cities
Threads: @nerd4cities
Twitter: @nerd4cities

----------

Music:
CityNerd background: Caipirinha in Hawaii by Carmen María and Edu Espinal (YouTube music library)

----------

Business Inquiries: [email protected]

All Comments (21)
  • @CityNerd
    So I went and made a 20 minute video that explains everything you could POSSIBLY want to know about I-94, and that wasn't enough? You STILL had to go and read the comments?? Well. This right here is the comment you came for. Sign up for Nebula and you'll get my videos early, ad-free, AND with no promotional pitches for, like, VPNs, or backpacks made out of recycled water bottles, or...like Nebula itself. Oh, and better yet, NO COMMENT SECTION! Use my custom link to get 40% off an annual subscription, and help support my channel on a creator-owned streaming platform. go.nebula.tv/citynerd Bonkers lifetime deal still available too! go.nebula.tv/lifetime?ref=citynerd
  • @MrStrickland90
    the irony of us calling I-75/85 in atlanta ‘the connector’ when it tore apart the fabric of the city
  • @SirTurboDave
    The inner loop project in Rochester, NY is a great example of what can be achieved when filling in freeways. After just doing the eastern section, we've seen hundreds of millions of dollars worth of development that includes mixed-use buildings and a much prettier environment to exist in. We're now working on the northern part of the loop that will include beautifying the Amtrak station there and bringing back the street grid from 100 years ago. We're lucky that every single level of government (state, county, and city) is finally onboard for moving away from car dependency.
  • @apadgettski
    It might be because I’m a Minneapolitan, but this is my favorite video you’ve ever done. What a beautiful city with so much potential.
  • @rpvitiello
    Recessed urban freeways seem like the ideal location to build cut and cover style subway lines, since the cut par is already done. Then build needed high density housing above it.
  • @mattgalper5397
    I'm not so sure that some of these state DOTs wouldn't build an "I-94" today. Texas and even California come to mind. Both are either trying to expand highways in city centers or are building new ones through residential neighborhoods. Even in Pennsylvania we still waste our money on crap like this though not through any major city centers in recent years.
  • @theshireling
    "Acknowledgement isn't the same as repair" Well said, ODOT made a similar statement as they ready their plans to widen I-75 through Cincinnati to 20 lanes in some places. Thank you Reconnecting Communities...
  • If 94 and 35 get covered my life will improved greatly. It totally disconnects south Minneapolis from downtown. The 35/94/55 cross over is hellish
  • 1:30 In this animation it is entirely appropriate that this dystopian highway compares the years 1984 and 1947. Coincidentally, the numbers correspond to the novel “1984” and the year of the novels first draft.
  • @jpberka
    Thanks for this video. I wrote a paper on this very project when a student at the U of MN years ago. I had a professor argue with me that she saw the interstates as creators of freedom. I tried to use Rondo as my defense of my opposition to her argument, but she wasn't having it.
  • @cantin8697
    1:34 This really does visually put into perspective how people's homes are bulldozed for road projects. Very depressing.
  • Twin Cities resident here. I work right off the Olson Memorial Hwy in Golden Valley, MN I travel on that road and 94 into the South St Anthony neighborhood to satellite offices for work. I try my best to avoid any freeways as much as possible when I go from office to office. I really like the ideas that Our Streets is trying to put out. (I even follow them and Laura the board president on X). Even tho I live way out in an outer ring suburb, I really want the metro to become and even more desirable place to live and make it more walkable and transit oriented. Like I said I live in an outer ring suburb, if the transit was more convenient to take to work I definitely would.
  • @fallenshallrise
    All these giant, multi-lane roads and highways cutting cities up like a pizza just encourage people to use our most populated areas as a shortcut from and to destinations outside of the city itself. The good news is that we have acres and acres of empty and free land in our urban centers that we can turn into millions of affordable leasehold apartments, row houses, low cost retail and greenspace.
  • It's really nice to see that MNdot is actually acknowledging what the highways did and how bad they are. I feel like there is a ton of states that would never happen
  • @Jonsolski18
    Living in downtown Kansas City, the north side of the downtown freeway loop could easily be another candidate for freeway removal like this. Great ideas here!
  • @Zeyev
    Yet another case showing how States were allowed to violate the original purpose of the "interstate" and "defense" highways concept by routing through cities instead of NEAR cities. A tragedy still unfolding. Thanks for highlighting this one dreadful example.
  • you don't understand Mr. City Nerd, I LOVE pm 2.5 and other carcinogens! they're a symbol of freedom
  • @Skip6235
    I’m from Detroit, and with all the hullabaloo about the decommissioning of I-375, I thought that it was going to be some sort of urbanist dreamland utopia. Instead they are turning it from an 8-lane limited access freeway into a 6-lane massive arterial stroad. So. . .progress?
  • @cheeto9
    Minneapolis has been undergoing a huge urban transformation since 2005, by 2050 we will look nothing like we used to - a lot better in my opinion. 2000-2050 is largely undoing the woes of what we did 1950-2000