Is Israel breaking the rules of war?

124,891
0
Published 2023-10-20
The Economist’s defence editor Shashank Joshi spoke to legal experts to find out whether Israel’s response to Hamas’s terrorist attack is lawful.

00:00 - Is Israel breaking the rules of war?
00:59 - Blockade
01:32 - Bombardment

Sign up to The Economist’s daily newsletter: econ.st/3QAawvI

Is Israel acting within the laws of war?: econ.st/3tzVBv7

Joe Biden steers a risky course after a Gaza hospital blast: econ.st/3ty6RIl

Mapping Israel’s war in Gaza: econ.st/3M5xECv

Hamas tunnels under Gaza will be a key battlefield for Israel: econ.st/490c8ZG

To save Palestinian lives in Gaza, open the crossing into Egypt: econ.st/3M3PzJu

A short history of Gaza: econ.st/408EJYR

Israel faces the danger of fighting on a second front: econ.st/3twmikn

Will Israel’s agony and retribution end in chaos or stability?: econ.st/48RGPQI

Netanyahu wages war and fights for his own survival: econ.st/3Q0xDku

Hamas’s attack was an Israeli intelligence failure on multiple fronts: econ.st/3Q9Rgrp

Brutal urban warfare awaits Israel’s army in Gaza: econ.st/3tw0vJJ

By Invitation: The crisis shows the failure of Israeli policy towards Palestinians, says Shlomo Brom: econ.st/3FhRzKl

By Invitation: Nimrod Novik on the false premises and failure of vision that led to the Hamas attacks: econ.st/3LWaXAx

1843: “It’s an Anne Frank situation”: an Israeli professor hides from Hamas: econ.st/3RO3Qh9

Watch: Israel and the Palestinians: a century of conflict: econ.st/3ZS68hf

Listen: With no electricity, limited internet and dwindling food supplies, what is life like in Gaza?: econ.st/3PRoaM9

Listen: An interview with a senior political leader of Hamas: econ.st/3rMPIua

All Comments (21)
  • @Giveitasub
    Yes 100% the law is law they are breaking the law,
  • @Mohassen5
    I feel pain, unable to do anything. And the world couldn’t be able to do anything. The sad thing is that it is supported by the west that claims to be the champion of democracy and human rights.
  • Media keeps addressing symptoms and not the root of the pain and problem.
  • @myrmoi
    I don't understand Isalm's logic. When they broke the rules of war, no one talk about it and then suddenly they became a victims, then they keeps saying follow the rules of the war. Same thing: Many islamic countries, close down Christian churches to renovate to mosque but when Christian countries do, they says it is religious persecution.
  • @robertidenya1432
    These two guys should agree to a world wide legal campaign to state their claims to the land and whomever loses should be compelled to accept the verdict. These war they wage at every turn of a year is wearing the world down, affecting commerce, anxiety...the world needs peace.
  • @HibHab69
    Maybe someone should tell Hamas the rules of war, too.
  • I think it’s safe to assume that in this conflict only one side will be anywhere close to playing by the rules of war.
  • @HebeYuan-xd8xr
    Hope people all love peace and can enjoy peace , enjoy family stay together.
  • I think that the fact that there is only one side of this conflict that people are even bothering to talk to about "rules of war" with any hope that they would listen tells you all you need to know about this conflict...
  • @moggpiano8043
    Rules? What rules? When the chips are down, such regulations are tossed out of the window.
  • @Brahimfel
    So The Palestinians have the right to deffend them selves using force also ... Who is invading the other ?
  • @jansport0409
    When the blockade is mentioned everyone conveniently forgets that Egypt does the same on their portion of the border.
  • @Shane-zl9ry
    Name a war that did not break international law. 🤔
  • @ctothaz
    Yes, they are. But so is Hamas.
  • @lastChang
    Why is the Chinese 🇨🇳 regime backing Hamas organization and committing Muslim Uyghur genocide at the same time?
  • @bendoverson4738
    They have not followed international law for decades. Why would they start now?