NO MORE COMFREY IN THE PERMACULTURE ORCHARD

It's fine to say no to comfrey if conditions don't suit it, but it's great for me; I crop mine FOUR times a year for liquid feed. Its leaves are low in cellulose, so it decomposes very quickly, making it ideal for the purpose. I have the tastiest potatoes & tomatoes as a result.

Confrey is also known in ancient times as 'knit bone'. Romans for example, set a broken bone, and made a comfrey poultice to use over the break. Bones healed very quickly. The leaves are edible but in small quantities and for short periods of time (it is hard on the liver). Comfrey can send down a tap root a whopping 12 FEET. It takes a piece of root as little as 1/4" chunk to start another comfrey plant. It's leaves contain a concentrated amount of minerals. Use it in the compost bin, side dressing for other plants, or to make a comfrey fertilizer tea. Of course for medicinal value too but check with a Dr on using it. Borage is in the same family but is an annual and the oil from the seeds is used for medicinal purposes. Comfrey does need fertilization (soil amendments) to grow and regular watering. Be forewarned that once established it is pretty hard to kill. It can take a whole year to kill a plant. Comfrey does not grow well in containers BUT if you use a clay pot with a hole in the bottom, plant a sprig of comfrey root, it will grow. It sends a root out the bottom hole. A year later pick up the pot and cut off the root. You made a clone. And the one in the pot can still grow and make another clone by repeating the above. Choose your location wisely!

Well, comfrey does GREAT where I live and I have tons of it. I'll stick with my comfrey, it works well for me.

I put it near my compost pile to recapture leached nutrients. It loves its location.

I've discovered I like big weeds. Little weeds are hard to get rid of. Big weeds are easily turned into great compost.

I don't understand how that comfrey isn't growing more vigorously. It grows in every possible condition for me. I have it in shade, sun, dry, wet, barron, and fertile areas. It all grows like a weed everywhere.

I have Bocking 14 Comfrey that has sterile seed, meaning I can only propagate it by cutting a piece of the root and replanting. It’s amazingly healthy everywhere I’ve planted it. I plan on growing more this year for the chickens. Good video.

Comfreys great, I have a market garden on a slope, one section of hillside has a vertical drop of like a foot and a half. The soils just clay, and a year ago I planted a whole row of comfrey on the side of the steep bank. It worked great, the deep knotted roots have completely stabilised the bank, no erosion. The plants have grown positively massive with no attention and once they get too big I simply use the leaves as fresh green mulch to break down around other food plants/fruit trees I grow. It's a real useful plant to just take up space if you don't want weeds to colonise that bare space instead.

My comfrey is gigantic, even when there is no good soil, it grows like crazy, attracts pollinators and makes a great compost tea...

Kinda interesting to see all the negative comments. I thought the message is fairly clear... if a plant doesn't grow well in your area (or in your soil), grow something else. I live in a dry, arid area and can't be bothered to plant comfrey (or mullein which might grow substantially better). Why not grow a native plant in its place? They grow like weeds.

Our comfrey tripled its first year. We use it for medical balm and the chickens and bunnies love it. Cincinnati, Ohio USA

I appreciate the soil I have very much. I planted small comfrey starts last year--they are now blooming and as tall as I am at 5'4". I never watered or fed it. Its helping me reclaim a spot that was growing toxic black walnut trees. thanks for the video.

I have a comfrey cultivar that does not reseed. It is on a hillside with poor dry soil and I never water it. It sends up a large clump of plants that get nearly 4 feet high and covered with beautiful flowers. After a rain it fell in all directions and sent up a new flush even fuller than the first. This massive plant grows in an ever expanding clump that again, never reseeds.

I have my comfery up near my house on a southern exposure where it gets plenty of sun and it is huge onky planted two plants and it is growing in clay

You can't expect of water lilies to grow in the sandy desert - comfrey is a plant of moist environment - plant it around the pond and you'll have your weeds.

well said- the best plant to use is usually the one already growing and thriving in place. Their role is to build and correct the soil deficit for some botanist and ecologist; many other plants have deep root system indeed- But nature as its own way to build soil and make soil life richer and set conditions for further species to germinated and establish.

I am speechless and thrilled at the information coming from these videos. I have a memory disorder but I think your use of principles will help me follow your methods. Many thanks.

I plant my comfrey next to trees too! I figure it will help bust up the clay. But in very dry areas it dies quick. Now i know why.

The comfrey in my garden grows about four feet high, and makes a potent liquid compost. Feed my runner beans with it the leaves are as big as plates and deep green in colour, and the beans are big and healthy to. The liquid compost has quite a fragrance with it and when I water with it, it seems to draw dung flies from miles around.

It seems to me the science of permaculture seems to get ahead of itself. I guess its the label to use for the way I garden, but I always figured the best soil fixers, cover crops, and bug feeders is native wildflowers. just sprinkle the seeds and your work is done.