Ancient Mesopotamian Warfare in Sumer and Akkad

Thanks to Curiosity Stream for sponsoring the video. Go to curiositystream.com/DanDavis and enter the promo code ‘DanDavis’ for 25% off an annual plan. And thank you very much for watching.

I like how the story of David and Goliath is considered the ultimate story of defeating the odds, but no matter how big Goliath was a stone from a sling to the head was a killing blow. Literally a weapon of warfare

A common non-military reason to build city walls was to collect tolls.

Those clay bullets were still somewhat in use when I was deployed to Iraq in 2008. I was stationed in a Theater Internment Facility providing medical care to Iraqi detainees. They would sometimes mix their tea with sand, make it into a ball, and leave it out in the sun to bake. Most of the time, they used them to lob messages back and forth between separate compounds, but they did occasionally use them as weapons, throwing them at us from time to time.

Halfway through I realized this video was 50 minutes long; it felt like 5! You really make these artifacts come alive and tell such rich but easy to follow stories!

Highly underrated channel. Dan’s story telling approach to history is so refreshing.

The idea that bullet design is at least 5000 years old is mindblowing to me

So glad we have someone covering these incredibly important but much less well known periods. These very early civilizations are endlessly fascinating.

About the capes with armor plating, this would be rather cumbersome but the added defensive bonuses (especially for skirmishers) for troops using hit and run tactics to not catch a sling stone to the back on the way out of range was huge. Japanese samurai wore a similar device that would catch air as the fled and inflate like a balloon, stopping arrows in the void created by the rush of air.

I'm pretty sure he just goes by Carl now

experts on ancient combat and weaponry made extensive research into the equipment and fighting style of the retiarius. they found that the net was not very useful at all against a skilled armed fighter. it was there more for the style that the retiarius had to uphold (like all the other types of gladiators who all had their style which included elements that we of no practical use) if net was used by the Sumerians and Akkadians, it was most likely to hunt unarmed civilians who were to become slaves. after all you don't want to damage the merchandise :)

It's not even my birthday but it sure as hell feels like it. Ancient Mesopotamia is where my interest lies the most. I love history but esecially these times all the way up to the Bronze Age Collapse are so incredibely interesting! Thanks for these amazing documentaries!

Didn't think I'd care about another Sumer / Akkad video, but you nailed it

Nobody else puts everything together like this. Outstanding work!

Hope you do a video on the Assyrians. Their towering lamassu, depictions of mutilated foes in their art, alongside the gorgeous lion hunt scenes and even depictions of siege crafts. Incredibly evocative, awe inspiring stuff.

Let out an audible "yesssss" when I saw this was out

I personally feel that it's likely that the Steele of Vultures is depicting an actual formation. Firstly throughout history whenever artists are depicting Phalanx/Spear Wall like formations they tend to do it in this way, by having loads of overlapping spears, we see this both in purely artistic depictions and in military manuals and that's probably just because it's a simple way to depict that formation. Secondly a spear wall type formation is just a really simple and easy formation to come up with while also being incredibly effective, there's a reason why this formation has been independently invented and reinvented several times throughout history, it's easy to train soldiers to be effective in this formation and it's easy to come up with. It's just sorta the natural thing to do if you have a bunch of dudes with spears and shields to think "what if we lined them all up with their spears pointing towards the enemy and the shields overlapping", even children playing with wooden weapons tend to come up with this idea as well even though they have little exposure to history. It might not have been anything as advanced as say the Phalanx, which was a much more complex formation than just having dudes with spears line up. But it seems highly likely that the Sumerians had probably invented some basic military formations like a spear wall if they had been conducting warfare on any kind of scale. It's basically unheard of for armies to fight completely uncoordinated if they have any significant experience or come from any kind of organized state. On the other hand I think it is going too far to conclude that they had standardized equipment based on the similarity in this Steele. That seems more like artistic shorthand to me plus it probably looked more impressive to have them all be fairly well equipped. It's just significantly easier to depict a bunch of completely identical dudes rather than giving them all individual gear, plus the artist very likely did not see the battle for themselves and were just told what happened and thus probably didn't know what the soldiers were actually wearing. They were probably just told something along the lines of "this many spearmen were present" and just drew that. Again looking at other historical depictions of battles it's rare that artists actually depict the gear accurately, often it's depicted as fairly identical even in battles where we know for a fact the armies didn't have standardized equipment such as on the Bayeux Tapestry, where both sides seem to be wearing roughly the same gear with only a few differences in colors and weapons. In general in historical depictions of battles they only displayed differences in equipment when it mattered to them, such as showing the banner or emblem of a specific lord/king, so in medieval depictions of battles you can often see a lot of banners because the monk drawing it wanted us to know who was there but they all wear basically the same armor. This is mostly just because artists were rarely present for the battles they were depicting and so just depicted whatever they thought a soldier looked like, you can usually glean some general info about equipment from this such as which weapons were the most common (in this case spears but in the Bayeux Tapestry there's a lot of swords) and what the armor of that period generally looked like, this Steele clearly shows helmets in a very specific pointed shape so that was probably a common design for helmets in this period because these are things the artist probably did know. The shape of the shield also seems notable, it seems really square which is a rare shape for shields to have, the only other square shields we really know of are the Roman scutum. Essentially when trying to glean information from artistic depictions of warfare you have to consider what exactly the artist might have known, if you know anything about modern warfare you'd know just how inaccurately movies and games portray that, but like some details from them are correct such as tanks existing and their general shape, the same would have been the case for historic art about warfare. There are general biases that tend to stay true throughout history such as a tendency to always depict everyone as wearing the best and most impressive armor and having the best gear, that's a bias that holds true to this day with how games and movies love to focus on hyper advanced weapons and special ops soldiers. Also as a sidenote those helmets were probably almost definitely bronze because leather armor isn't really a thing. It's probably a case of either the soldiers wore bronze helmets or they wore a woolen cap.

Very good content packed into a storyline that's condensed enough to avoid bogging down in mind numbing academic minutiae, but with the right amount for a decent understanding. The flow or cadence of the narrative is superb which makes Dan's videos so enjoyable to hear and learn.

Been studying this part of history & even it's mythology a ton lately, in preparation for my next episode. This is yet another sync encountered in my research. skål 💪🏽🐻

48:07 What a beautiful image of Shemitic fighting.