Q&A #17: Bullpups, Stocked Pistols, Delayed Blowback, and More!

479,432
0
Published 2018-04-24
www.patreon.com/ForgottenWeapons

Cool Forgotten Weapons merch! shop.bbtv.com/collections/forg...

0:26 - Can roller delayed blowback system be relevant in modern guns?
3:32 - Difference between gas tappet and short stroke gas piston
6:00 - Cleaning procedure, particularly for corrosive ammunition
7:32 - Brief synopsis of Yugoslavian post-WWII Mausers
10:45 - Final weight of WWSD carbine
11:44 - What hindered automatic arms development during WWI?
16:55 - Why not use MLOK/Keymod for optics?
18:05 - Forward-acting gas pistons?
19:26 - My opinion on the Remington bankruptcy
22:18 - Will 3D printing allow squeeze-bore rifles?
25:39 - What was the last US cavalry carbine?
26:20 - When the the Potato Digger leave US service?
28:11 - What was the first gun I bought specifically as a collectible?
28:55 - Is the FAMAS the best bullpup ever?
33:59 - What nation is underappreciated in small arms design history?
36:28 - Stocked pistols and modern arm brace pistols
41:04 - Do I approach museums and collectors or do they approach me?
42:46 - What is the Segway of modern guns?
44:40 - Are British DP (Drill Purpose) guns safe to shoot?
48:30 - What is the process to buy a machine gun in the US?
54:32 - Soviet TKB-59 triple barreled prototype
57:11 - Would modern high speed cameras have helped gun designers of the past?
58:48 - Why did primer-actuated systems never catch on?
1:01:44 - Progress on MAS-38 SMG and 7.65 French Long ammo
1:04:17 - What are the missing US designations, like rifles M2 through M13?

As always, questions came from Patrons at the $2/month level and above. Thanks to all of you for the support!

If you enjoy Forgotten Weapons, check out its sister channel, InRangeTV! youtube.com/InRangeTVShow

Contact:
Forgotten Weapons
6281 N Oracle #36270
Tucson, AZ 85704

All Comments (21)
  • @BeasBotBonanza
    'How much of a gun guy are you?' Ian: 'Well I use boxes of cartridges as book holders for my massive library of gun books, does that answer your question?'
  • @ThrowingItAway
    Shout out to all those collectors who share their guns so that they can be shown to everyone.
  • @Oblithian
    I am not even obsessed with guns like some people, I just like mechanical things. You make the content interesting Ian thank you.
  • @Antigonus.
    'What Would Saint-Étienne Do?' FAMAS series confirmed for 2019?
  • @eyeamstrongest
    the french, finns, italians, and japanese are all definitely underappreciated in the world of firearms design
  • @ristoalanko9281
    The best gun cleaning "solution" is hot water. I do a lot of black powder shooting and could'nt live without it. When I was doing my 11 months in national service in Finnish Army, I once cleaned my heavily fouled RK62 (lots of blank ammo!) in hot shower. It was the cleanest gun I have ever seen, and our armory sergeant said: " Yes, clean, but the next time gets you 10 days in the cage!". Oil and lots of scrubbing only after that...
  • "Everything in firearms design is a compromise" Oof I'm telling Hk on you
  • @connclark2154
    There is something to add on buying a machine gun. Some states don't allow possession of machine guns. So the the first step would be to move to a state that allows it or change the state law.
  • @jamesjross
    The Pipe! You're just spreading it on thick at this point.
  • @asadunbar999
    one day Ian is going to be that 100yr old dood that knows EVERYTHING about guns, machining processes, history etc. he's well on his way. Excellent class, bud, the robe has got me cracking up (sips a tea mug). love your show, keep up the good work.
  • @Camocheese
    I had always wondered about those "missing" weapon designations. Today I learned something new. Nice.
  • @rollover4894
    i found a mauser in my grandpas house with 1899 and serbian coat of arms on the reciver
  • @Locutus494
    32:10 The Desert Tech MDR should definitely be mentioned here! I realize it's new and no one has a lot of experience with it, and it's also not a military gun, but it should definitely be a contender! If it can bring Karl around regarding bullpups, it must be good! ;)
  • @candidmoe8741
    Dear Gun Jesus: You have to write a book about mechanics aspects of gun, the how and why of different actions (blockback, gas, ...). With illustrations and diagrams. It looks like nobody written one before, and even Internet is severely lacking in that regard; your videos being the most extensive coverage of the matter I ever found.
  • @BlackhartFilms
    I'd like to add on the point of 3D printing that additive manufacturing is inherently weaker in design than most other methods. In plastic, for example, an injection moulded part can be very very strong because the liquid polymer can cool into a single monolithic piece. In additive manufacturing you have each layer cool individually one on another, which creates a kind of "wood grain" to the final product. The danger of delamination means that extra care has to be put into planning layer directions in stress bearing parts. In that case, something like a single weld makes more sense- like your WWSD lowers. The honeycomb internal is made possible by casting the parts in two halves then welding them. Yes that makes the seam a weak point, but that's better than hundreds or thousands of them in a print.
  • @oc-j6039
    With what you said about the L85 being too heavy, don’t worry the MoD listened and the new A3 is a whole 100 grams lighter!!!!
  • @IanDinBC
    Re: Squeeze or taper bores, the Colt Canada cold hammer forged barrels used in the C7 and C8 series of rifles have a very slight taper to the bore, as well as an in-line forging of the chamber. It doesn't require 3D printing, just a carefully hammer forged barrel around a mandrel with a taper machined into it.