Q&A 56: Travel, Elbonian Snipers, and Contradictions

237,966
0
Published 2021-12-21
www.patreon.com/ForgottenWeapons

www.floatplane.com/channel/ForgottenWeapons/home

Cool Forgotten Weapons merch! shop.forgottenweapons.com

It's Q&A time again! The last one for 2021...here's to hoping 2022 is a better year for everyone.

0:00:00 - Introduction
0:00:21 - My passport, and customs
0:01:54 - What countries would I like to visit?
0:04:46 - How much FR-F2 practice did I have before Desert Brutality?
0:06:07 - Why not half-brass rifle or pistol ammo, like in shotguns?
0:07:46 - Why aren't there more closed bolt SMGs?
0:09:40 - Why no more hexagonal barrels?
0:10:53 - Forgotten Weapons videos on Amazon
0:12:27 - "Economical" machine guns
0:17:28 - FN49 in different calibers
0:19:07 - Sniper rifles for Elbonia
0:21:25 - Was there an 8mm Lebel Maxim gun?
0:23:59 - Details on Ethiopian Oddities
0:26:54 - Some WWSD complaints mirroring original M16 complaints
0:29:36 - What rifle should France have made for new smokeless powder?
0:31:13 - Choice for a 2-Gun match: Carcano, Enfield, Arisaka
0:33:25 - Why wasn't the CETME AMELI more common?
0:34:31 - A gun I have been searching for unsuccessfully
0:37:32 - Why not smaller cartridges with more powerful powder?
0:40:02 - Seemingly contradictory good guns (M3 vs PPSh-41)
0:44:11 - How does stamping allow cheaper metals?
0:47:03 - Match for revolvers and single shot rifles
0:50:04 - Pedersen vs Johnson if there was no Garand
0:52:40 - "Not real" actions like Blish...and API
0:54:57 - Printed magazines for very rare guns?
0:57:14 - Which will be dropped first, 9mm or 5.56mm?
0:59:27 - Biggest military lesson form World War One?
1:02:06 - Did Simonov see an RSC rifle?
1:03:13 - Unlimited ammo from Santa: what caliber and for what guns?

Contact:
Forgotten Weapons
6281 N. Oracle 36270
Tucson, AZ 85740

All Comments (21)
  • At some point you’re gunna have to enter a two gun match as an Elbonian infantryman
  • @terry7907
    “Russia has some visa issues and diplomatic issues right now”. Ian, the master of understatement.
  • @ravenslaves
    The proud nation of Elbonia doesn't need the fancy sniper weapons of the West. Our proud sniper corps has always distinguished itself with honor as one of the most highly decorated units in the World. To see them standing in ranks in their bright orange battle dress uniforms with their gleaming displays of wound badges, shining in the Sun, has inspired the entire nation for over 400 years.
  • Elbonian snipers account for bullet drop, by mounting the scope under the barrel.
  • @jrs4516
    that fact that ian doesn't even know the correct name of "raid: shadow legends" fill's me with hope.
  • @dvogonen
    According to the museum database of Sweden's Royal Armoury (Livrustkammaren), the museum has two Kalthoff rifles in their inventory (inventory number 3646 (31:16) and 3644 (1334)) . You might be able to visit them and have a look at the rifles if you communicate with them in advance. They have some 30 000 items in their collection, so the rifles are probably not on display. Due to Swedish history, the collection is especially rich on items and weapons from the 17th century.
  • @ackshually404
    "Raid shadows legend" I love that he is so disinterested in stupid sponsors that he gets their name slightly wrong. I really appreciate your dedication to keeping this ad free and community based. Thank you ian
  • @BatCaveOz
    I suspect that the significant reduction in weight between the Thompson vs the M3 Grease Gun endeared the M3 to anyone that had to carry one in the field.
  • @Vilamus
    Regarding machine guns, I think a unit of price should be "Lago Aliens", as in, affordable machine guns are about 2-3 Lago Aliens.
  • @b79holmes
    I think a future t-shirt run needs to include an 'Elbonian Armorers' shirt
  • @jameslawrie3807
    Ian's the first ever person who's said the words "I'd like to visit Lithgow".
  • @anlizheng6134
    On the "Which will be replaced first, 9mm or 5.56mm?" question, don't we see the answer already in historical terms? 9mm Parabellum has been around since 1901, when military rifles were generally firing full-power 7-ish millimetre cartridges. Since then, military rifle cartridges first went "intermediate" by shortening but keeping around the same calibre (8mm Short, 7.62x39), and then to "small calibre" rounds like 5.56mm, 5.45mm, 5.8mm and even 4.7mm in the H&K G11. Meanwhile, the 9x19mm cartridge has soldiered on, becoming steadily more popular. Rifle ammunition development has historically been much more dynamic than pistol, presumably because rifles are more important militarily than pistols, as Mr McCollum points out.
  • @18robsmith
    Additional to your selection of the M14 isn't it the case that the Elbonians received the "complete" 128 page manual. Their top brass read the first few pages.... only later was it discovered that pages 33-127 were blank, and these pages covered the re-assembly and re-bedding of these guns. Page 128 being the outside back cover, which any fool could see was just a printer's aberration page.
  • @MTimWeaver
    Re Polymer rifle ammo: When I ran Practical Tactical back in the day, I obtained some of the polymer cased ammo that was being reintroduced into the market, around 2006-07 time frame. I think the mfg was Natec. Anyway, I ran it during one of the annual Independent Day Rifle Matches at Rio Salado. It was 114 that day. Most of the day, it ran fine up until the last stage with the concrete 'bunker' to shoot from, then a shoot house. By the time i got into the shoothouse, I got to the second target and it just went click. I did a tap/rack/bang, and same. Locked the slide back, dropped the mag, inserted a fresh mag, and same thing. Looking into the ejection port, I could see the tip of the round trying to enter the chamber, but wasn't. I cleared the gun, walked off the range to a safe area and checked the chamber...the polymer had gotten so hot, the extractor ripped the brass base off the case. I had to wait about 10-15 mins for it to cool enough to pop the plastic case out with a cleaning rod. I gave the ammo away the next day (I hadn't been charged for it). Gave the recipient a "use this for plinking ammo, not for competitions or defense" and was done with it. It was great, right up until it wasn't. :)
  • @iJacker
    “You’ll never see a Raid Shadow Legend ad on here” ha! Ian you’re a badass
  • @jic1
    48:39 You missed a circle for your Venn diagram: the cowboy shooters. They frequently use single-shot rifles for side matches.
  • @aaronhrk
    You have to get to the Australian War Memorial Ian. My best mate is a senior curator there and can get you behind the scenes access. It is an amazing museum with a fantastic collection of many extremely rare artefacts ❤
  • @darthhodges
    If advance primer ignition was relevant to submachine gun designs like the grease gun or UZI out of battery detonations would be FAR more common. In fixed firing pin guns the firing pin is in physical contact with the primer long before the case is far enough into the chamber to safely detonate it. It's not until something tries to stop movement of the cartridge that the firing pin applies enough force to set it off.