Do The New Total Drama Island Seasons Suck?

7,953
0
Published 2024-07-14
Contains spoilers for both seasons of the reboot.

The reboot showed promise but had numerous rough patches, particularly in the second season.

All Comments (21)
  • To my knowledge, the allegations about Christian Potenza were proven to be false in a podcast. He was on a while ago. It should still be up.
  • @dav_cosico05
    i liked the two recent seasons but one problem is how they kept milking julia and priya characters in the 2nd season when other characters deserved to shine
  • @_z_873
    I liked the first reboot season a lot, easily top 3 season (excluding the raptor episode), the second one was... eh? The first half was fun, the ending 3 episodes were fun, the rest wasn't
  • @weforgotsammy
    in my opinion, i dont think it sucks, it def isnt the best season but its got its moments
  • @anamarinax
    I like Bowie. One of the best chars of the show. Scary Girl as well, she's great! Milli sucks, tbh.
  • I think Lauren could have worded her speech in S2 a little better. I understood what she meant, but it did come across as a little creepy. I may be in the minority
  • Still think the final season be total drama champions every past winner in one final game plus the winners of the race spinoff
  • @dubhedubhe
    To be honest, with the hot mess that was S2, I think in the unlikely chance they pull out a third season with this cast, they're gonna have to make an Island or World Tour level of good season to get themselves out of the hole that has been dug. No more milking Priya and Julia, give characters like Nichelle and Scary Girl an actual role in the season and time to grow as characters, fix that bad ships so we either just don't have to deal with them or make them salvageable at the very minimum, make moves actually be shown and developed, and make the eliminations BELIEVABLE. Thanks for listening to my TED Talk.
  • @marionbaggins
    Australia didn’t get the Reboot until 2024 in March.
  • Season 1 was good and season 2 was insanely bad Legit the second season soft resets everything that happened in the first, Julia seemingly has no backlash at all from last season yet Bowie and Priya are seen as major threats and villains, Zee was a lot less funny, and a lot of the late game eliminations were weird and just existed to prolong Caleb and Priya having a godawful love story on par with the World Tour Gwuncan romance
  • @StaciROTIbi
    Inb4 guy is gonna claim Disventure Camp is a writing masterpiece way better than TD because it doesn't focus on jokes
  • @idk1586
    HOW DO YOU ONLY HAVE 119 SUBS GRRRRR (underrated ☺️)
  • One time when I was on the YouTube channel stream, Total Drama Official, I asked if there was a season 3 Reboot and they said: "You need to watch reboot season 1 in order to find out." So, by this quote, I am thinking there may be a new season. (I have a screenshot if you want proof)
  • It don't sucks the only sucks is all stars but at least total drama island series is back
  • @Rywdb
    In regards to MKs skin tone, I think both were fine, I interpreted it as having more specifically Southeast asian representation Though I don't speak for every asian and can definitely see how it can be offensive, so her new skin tone is fine
  • @Tdifan_jay
    I think the 1st reboot season is GREAT But the 2nd season... not so much