The Moment The FNAF Timeline BROKE

The first step in being a FNAF theorist is coming to terms with the fact that you will be doing this for the rest of your life with no final answer. The second step is that Phone Guy is the Purple Guy.

you know when a fandoms off the deep end when we start making theories about if theorizing is even possible

I don’t even think that Scott knows wtf is happening anymore 💀

my theory: Scott started by making up the lore as he went, only to realize too late how screwed up his timeline was and is tricking the fans into making one for him.

The fact that John can still find NEW things in old fnaf games and make connections I have never heard anyone else make before is insane to me 🤯

I sincerely think Scott should work with Steel Wool to remake the first four/five games and release them as a "FNAF Classics Remastered" collection, changing and/or removing every piece of lore that has been retconned or turned irrelevant over the years. A version of those games that is actually made with the current story in mind, knowing they won't be the final games (cough, FNAF 3 and 4, cough). Either that or just give us a plain list of details that don't matter or aren't canon anymore. Now that the series presumably has a better story direction than just Scott building one game on top of the other, not even knowing when the series is supposed to end, we really need those old weeds removed already.

With the way the timeline and lore seem to be jumping all over the place, I'm almost starting to believe in my own head canon that some of the games take part in different timelines.

Every time you make a theory it just turns my entire perception of this franchise upside down 💀

Is it just me or is John starting to resemble more and more Josh Hutcherson? John can easily play Josh's younger version in FNAF movies

what everyone can collectively agree on is that Scott DEFINITELY changed the timeline and is currently trying to “fix” it with the new games. I believe he has a definite plan now for the timeline and excited to hopefully learn more of the origins!

John having a mental breakdown had me pondering my own mental stability

something I like to remember people it's that all of this started because we were wondering who the hell would stay 5 nights after seing the murder animatronics, and then the random chance of the missing children poster made it all the more inticing even if Scott admitted it was just to spice things up. I think the value in fnaf is no longer in the games but in the community and dedication every single one of us puts into trying to make some sense of it, and coming up with different conclusions it's one of the best parts because it creates feedback, we inspire one another and together gather way more evidence than any single human could. I know there will always be some not so nice people in the community, but I think they can't stop the positive feedback different pointviews provide to the scene as a whole

Also something to note about that child, they wearing a shade of green very very close to the same exact shade of charlie's armband when she died. Could be coincidence, but the colors matching so closely is a bit suspect. Just a bit of potential supportive evidence. It also isn't the only time Charlie is associated with the color green.

Man, William got to be rich as hell to recreate a whole neightborhood underground

The most epic "man talking to camera in his bedroom about haunted animatronics" video ever

Scott lost the plot years ago. Retconning, lying to his fans, refusing to answer questions. His fans aren't ready to accept he has no idea what's going on anymore.

OR... Hear me out... The "Bunker" was an old Fallout Shelter and Afton never got around to filling it with the FunTime's Animatronics until later. Makes sense why it would be so deep underground.

John: uploads timeline based video Me: Ay let him cook John: (video image) well its maybe unsolvable Me: back to square one then

The four animatronics in the closets are Minireenas, they appear in this level in Help Wanted. It could also be Nightmare Balloon Boy in one because Scott said that he’s the only Halloween character canon to Fnaf 4.

the bit w u sitting on the floor is gold btw