If Luffy became a Marine

If Luffy became a Marine, Garp would be the happiest grandfather on Earth.

Now Zoro's title Pirate Hunter will remain Unchanged

No matter how he loves being a marine, I'm sure he won't abandon ace. I'm sure of it

I think Luffy's adventures as a marines wouldn't be so different in the end

If Luffy decides to be navy, Garp would be his sensei and teach all Haki types before the first time he started sailing (17 years old).

Garp was so happy that luffy said that he'll become the fleet admiral, so this is the one piece but marine version

Actually this plot / setting make more sense than being a Pirate King path cuz 90% of other pirates are evil and Luffy always try to act like a savior for wherever he visited.

In regards to the end, there's actually some fanfics I read many years ago that explore a "what if" scenario of Luffy being a marine and what would happen as a result of Ace's execution being announced. One of them had a neat idea (though of course a lot more anticlimactic than Marine Ford) that Luffy goes to Whitebeard and makes a deal - he retrieves Ace, they don't go all out on the marine headquarters. He gets clearance to enter Impel down, and rearrange the orders of the ships - it's more complex then my summary but basically Ace is put on one ship instead of the other and there's all the miscommunication of "no WE have him," "NO, WE have him!" and basically Luffy pulls what he did originally at Impel down, getting Ivankov and Bentham's assistance - massive prison break - "hey guys wait a second Ace is not on the ship we're on wtf" - Whitebeard Pirates slip in and take advantage of the chaos and free Ace. And essentially onward from that moment Luffy and his crew become fugitives, 2 time skip - suddenly a new Pirate crew called the strawhats pop up in the New World, and y'all know the rest.

After the one piece ended, this is definitely what I hope to watch next, Luffy as Marine.

Please continue this will be a good what if series. It has a VERY VERY big potential to be one of your finest what if work.

This is by far the most cleanest animation you have done. And I like how since he'll become a marine, the ribbon on his straw hat is of blue colour

In this timeline i could see Shanks still coming to luffy’s village hanging out, luffy eating the fruit and inspiring luffy to be a pirate but this time however when the bandits came and kidnapped luffy Shanks was to late to save him and just as luffy was about to be eaten it was Garp that saved him instead sacrificing his arm and in turn precious fist to save his grandson as Luffy was thankful for his grandfather he joined the marines while still holding respect for shanks as shanks gives him the hat telling him to give it back when he becomes a great marine but luffy still being luffy i see him not taking orders from his superiors doing everything his own way and still getting promoted none the less

Namy: "why would i ever join the marines!!" Sanji : "Have you seen admirals paycheck? Plus you can legally seize pirates treasures for yourself" Namy: "So anyways i'm a marine now"

Brooooo I don’t even know how I feel about this lol. To me Luffy is the great pirate of all time but damn him as a marine gave me chills

The crew would be a bit different, Coby would promise to join Luffy after he becomes stronger, Zoro wouldn't have trouble joining because it wouldn't interfere with his dream of becoming the Strongest Swordsman, Nami would be a bit reluctant to join due to Nezumi selling off her village but at the end she would join after seeing that Luffy's crew is how Marines are supposed to be. Ussop wanted to be a Brave Man of the Sea, his dream was not incompatible so he would join, the same going for Sanji. Smoker wouldn't chase after Luffy and remains at Roger's birth but suggests Tashigi to join Luffy's crew so she could get stronger. They still meet Laboon, Crocus and Vivi because Luffy wanted to see how pirates crossed the Red Line. The Alabasta Arc is almost the same with Luffy having less trouble to defeat Crocodile in their final battle, because in this reality they are Marines they are publicy lauded as heroes and get several promotions. Nico wouldn't join the crew, Luffy would let her escape after the Alabasta Arc, she probably be on her own again until the Revolutionaries find her. Luffy recognizes Blackbeard when they meet at the island below Skypea and they fight, it is a very hard battle but this Luffy was stronger than his canon self due to the training in Haki he got from Garp and wins, after Ace hears of that he returns with Whitebeard, during Luffy's recovery he is visited by Coby who joins his crew (Helmepo remains with Garp, wary of Zoro) In this reality they dont have the Sunny but a Marine ship, they don't travel to Water 7, without Robin around Luci and his group don't receive orders to act yet and remain as sleeping agents at Galey La Company. Luffy gets order to investigage Moriah, they meet Brook, Luffy offers him to join but he refuses because he is a pirate, after the Thriller Back arc ends Brooks agrees to join, Brook's bounty was already lapsed. Because they are not pirates they don't get Wanted posters, Duval is not hunted for resembling Sanji's portrait, he doesn't kidnap Hachi, Camie doesn't meet the crew and the Straw Hats don't have to free her. In the Sabaody Archpielago the imbecile Celestial Dragon still gets punched, in this case by Kidd. The Straw Hats come with Kizaru and everything goes relatively fine until they accidentally cross paths with Rayleigh who completely trashes them and takes away Luffy's hat after recognizing it, motivating Luffy to get stronger.

Essentially. Luffy became a naval marine.....and nothing in this timeline changed. Luffy still did the same things! I love it!🤣👏

Please make this a series

Wow oda-san really should make side story where luffy is marine it would be fun to watch. And please make the part 2 I really want to see what happens in summit war of marineford.

This is exactly what I think Luffy as a marine would be like, he would basically be the exact same, fighting other pirates/marines. However he would SPECIFICALLY defeat the "evil" marines. Either pirate or marine, Luffy is good.

It'd be great to see this version of One Piece, instead of making a pirate crew Luffy swings by and nabs the strawhats making one of the best Marine squads instead, WITH Coby on the team too