What can DNA tests really tell us about our ancestry? - Prosanta Chakrabarty

1,161,805
0
Published 2020-06-09
Dig into the science of how ancestry DNA tests work, their accuracy, and why tracing ancestry is so complicated.

--

Two sisters take the same DNA test. The results show that one sister is 10% French, the other 0%. Both sisters share the same two parents, and therefore the same set of ancestors. So how can one be 10% more French than the other? Tests like these rely on our DNA to answer questions about our ancestry, but DNA actually can’t tell us everything. Prosanta Chakrabarty explores the accuracy of DNA tests.

Lesson by Prosanta Chakrabarty, directed by Artrake Studio.

Animator's website: www.artrake.com/
Sign up for our newsletter: bit.ly/TEDEdNewsletter
Support us on Patreon: bit.ly/TEDEdPatreon
Follow us on Facebook: bit.ly/TEDEdFacebook
Find us on Twitter: bit.ly/TEDEdTwitter
Peep us on Instagram: bit.ly/TEDEdInstagram
View full lesson: ed.ted.com/lessons/what-can-dna-tests-really-tell-…

Thank you so much to our patrons for your support! Without you this video would not be possible! Leen Mshasha, Mariana Ortega, Danny Romard, James Bruening, Ricki Daniel Marbun, Malcolm Callis, Sabrina Gonzalez, Al the Scottish Wildcat, سلطان الخليفي, Alexander Walls, Della Palacios, Vik Nagjee, Hiroshi Uchiyama, Adi V, Andrew Bosco, Craig Sheldon, Rishi Pasham, Joanne Luce, Jason A Saslow, Mary Sawyer, Scott Gass, Ruth Fang, Mayank Kaul, Kathryn J Hammond, Max Shuai Tang, Terry Minion, Sami Khan, Rob Johnson, Abdullah Abdulaziz, Angelo Urzua-Milla, Tommy Lewis, leorene, Mahina Bachiller, Marcus Andre Nery, Bruce Vieira Lopes, Chef , Charmaine Hanson, Michael Goldberg, Lydia Pflieger, Paul Aldred-Bann, Manav parmar, Susan Wang, Utkarsh Dubey, Thawsitt, Xuebicoco, Jezabel, Maeve, Kim Humphrey and Kristen Damas.

All Comments (21)
  • @idib1739
    In these times of injustice and prejudice it's a great reminder that we're the same at 99%. thanks guys.
  • So basically, DNA tests don't show you your ancestry, but rather what ancestry you inherited.
  • @man4437
    I guess this explains why nobody recognizes me as the rightful heir to the Mongolian Kingdom
  • 23 and Me (DNA ancestry test): Exists TED-Ed: Let me end this test's whole career.
  • @mr.osmosis5713
    Welp, I guess DNA tests are more wonky than we thought.
  • @jbkkkkk
    DNA tests can be useful. We just confuse them as identity markers instead of tools. I found relatives on 23andme and reconnected my grandma with her cousin before he passed. I also found my other grandma's nephew and told him of her passing. And my ancestry results helped my geneology search.
  • @AtlanticPicture
    admit, had this in the background, but the way he talks i thought the vid was over at the end of every sentence
  • @gokulomega
    Genetic test : we can accurately predict your ancestry Ted : Swiggty swooty the test ain't your ancestry
  • @DemonixGamer
    It's not that the tests don't show you your ancestry, necessarily. Let me explain: 1) You don't get the same trait or percentage as your sibling from each parent, grandparent, or ancestor (hence why we do not look identical) 2) Most of the tests are based on modern day comparisons (unless you're running an ancestral database, like on Gedmatch, for example). 3) Not all of your 1% variance from other members of the modern human species is being tested. But this 1% determines what genetic-ethnicity you are. Not all of this 1% is tested equally - hence why different tests reveal different results. It's best to take an average between them and infer. 4) Humans are essentially the product of different hominids mixing, each hominid dependant on where they come from geographically. 5) Y-DNA goes back to a long line of males unchanged from your father going straight back, as does mtDNA for the mother's side, but only males can be tested for Y since we have that chromosome. DNA testing is complicated and nonlinear, but that doesn't mean it's pointless. It can reveal a lot about what you've inherited. Of course, just because you carry certain genes doesn't mean you'll express them all. It's best to believe with a healthy amount of skepticism.
  • @Geo-ye1lp
    One important thing left out of this video, likely for time, is mutation of genes. Many of these markers that tests look for are the difference between a single base pair, and the supposed ancestries they give you are based on how common these varieties of markers appear in certain regions based on their databases. However, your DNA mutates a lot, changing out one base pair for another. These markers are especially prone to being mutated and passed on, due to complicated DNA repair, genomic, and evolutionary mechanisms. Just because you might have one marker that looks like one found in France, does not mean you are French at all, since it is entirely possible (and perhaps likely) that you or an ancestor experienced a mutation that gave you the French-like version of that marker.
  • @brane4859
    All that is left is for you to answer "Where are we going?"
  • The sister when she realized she's 10% French: Bonjour! The other sister: Hi :<
  • @SMint-xo7vf
    Thank you, I was watching videos regarding those tests and I was a little overwhelmed and confused about them. Now it's clearer
  • @Neyobe
    “Like branches of a tree, our lives may grow in different directions. Yet our roots remain as one”- Wise person
  • @dorothy7657
    Video's thumbnail : what your dna can't tell you Video's title : what can dna tests really tell us... Smart way to trick the algorithm.
  • @matrinoxtm
    I knew it was possible for siblings to share 0% of the differing DNA but didn’t realize it’s possible to not share any DNA with grandparents and above (or conversely share a lot more DNA)
  • @samimeister
    This makes me so glad that I didn't order one of those dna tests to see my ancestry for fun